Setting realistic expectations on how much money you will receive when it comes time to sell a vintage baseball card collection

When the time for collectors, or relatives of collectors, to sell a vintage baseball card collection, most have no idea of its value or how much money they should expect to receive

It is important to have somewhat realistic expectations on what old Goudey, Bowman or Topps baseball cards are really worth, where to sell them or even how to begin the process. Hopefully, this article can help clear up some of the confusion.

A decade or so ago collectors were forced to consult Beckett's Baseball Card Price Guide and other similar guides to find out a card's estimated worth. I do not personally know of any professionals in the hobby that still consult traditional price guides to determine the value of vintage baseball cards or other sports cards.

The Beckett Price Guides lists a baseball card's "book value", which was basically an informed guess of a select number of "hobby experts". It was the best we had to go on at the time, but it in some cards was not very accurate. Today, with the help of online reporting and more consistent grading standards – written price guide are totally obsolete.

All too often sellers are surprised to learn that no one will offer them anywhere near the book values or even the historical sales prices for similar vintage baseball cards. Let’s talk about Book Values, suggested prices, or even historical records of actual sale prices of vintage baseball cards.

We grade more conservatively and consistently than anyone else in the hobby.

Colleen grading some of our vintage football cards.

  • The term “Book Value” usually refers to cards that are in Near Mint condition. Cards that grade "NEAR MINT" still have sharp corners, good centering and no gum stains or pen marks on the card. Very few vintage cards (less than 2%) grade as high as NEAR MINT. Since most cards were originally bought and handled by kids, a very low percentage of the cards remain in high quality condition. Most of the cards that I collected when I was a kid would be graded in FAIR to VERY GOOD Condition - which means that the card's Adjusted (for condition) Book Value is worth 10% to 30% of the Full Book Value! Even cards that are graded in "EXCELLENT" condition sell for a fraction the price of the cards in "Near Mint" condition. You can click here to see the Dean’s Cards guide to grading vintage baseball cards.
  • The reason that the book value of some cards is so high is that so few vintage cards remain in pristine condition. The Book Value of a card never really had much value to collectors. It is the Adjusted Book Value that is much more relevant to a vintage cards actual value.
  • The "Book Value" is the Suggested or the "Pie in the Sky" Price. Few collectors are willing to pay the book value price for cards. On the Dean's Cards website we list the Adjusted Book Value as the price of the cards, but we are forced to discount this price in the way of several discounts to remain competitive. Many cards will sell online for a fraction of their Adjusted Book Value.
  • Online Price Guides can also be very deceptive because of different grading standards.Even Professionally graded cards vary greatly from card-to-card, when they were graded and who submitted them for grading. Any business, that hopes to stay in business, provides special treatment to its best customers. Why would professional grading companies be any different?
  • Another reason that vintage baseball cards do not sell at full book values is that Card Dealers need to make a profit on the cards to cover their time and expenses. Most cards dealers have the expense of renting a table at a card show or in the case of Dean's Cards - the advertising, labor, and hosting expenses of a website. Not to mention it takes months (or years) to sell the cards that we have in inventory.
  • Non-Collectors almost always tend to over grade the condition of cards. Card Collectors can be very picky! You can read about grading vintage sports cards by visiting the "Dean’s Cards Guide to Grading Vintage Baseball Cards, but please realize that card grading takes years to perfect.
  • It is very common for a novice card seller to contact us and state "My cards are in MINT Condition". Very seldom does this turn out to be the case. Dean's Cards will certain buy vintage cards in almost any condition, but it is important to realize that the condition affects the value of the card.

    The good news is that - if you bought your cards as kid - you are going to make a great return on your investment. How many of your other childhood toys can you say this about?

    Selling your vintage baseball cards to Dean's Cards will net you a great return on investment.

    A great return on investment.

    To help put this into perspective, I have a great story about a Financial Investment Advisor that sold us a collection of his cards from the mid 1950's. This guy made a lot of money in his profession and his expectations were that he was going to make a fortune selling this collection. After all, he had read the stories of people making tons of money selling their collections. He checked a half a dozen dealers or so and told me, although Dean's Cards (by far) offered the most for his cards, he was still a little disappointed in the bid.

    First, I suggested that if he was still emotionally attached to the cards - then he should not sell them. After all, they are his cards. But I also wanted to help him put this in perspective so I broke it down into terms that he was familiar with. First, we figured out the original purchase price for the cards. We figured that he bought these 2000 cards in the 50's for a penny a piece (5 cards came in a Nickel Pack) to get the gum. That was a $20 investment.

    I forget the actual figures, but let's say that we offered him $1000 for the collection. This would be a return of 50 times his investment or 5000%! He was shocked. His comment was "I wish that I could get that return on my client's investments. We are doing great if we can average 15% per year for my clients!"

    The bottom line is that they are your cards and you certainly do not have to sell them. Many collectors never do sell the cards, until there is a special event which encourages them to do so for the money. Typical examples include: Weddings, Sending Kids to College or paying off a big bill. Most collectors keep the cards until they die and then let their heirs worry about what to do with the collection.

    Often there is too much of an emotional attachment for the seller to part with his "boyhood memories". The cards often sit in a closet until the original collector dies. I certainly understand this sentimental attachment and will probably never sell my personal collection. But if you have not looked at the cards in years, it may make sense to do something useful with the proceeds that you could get for the cards

    It is often the family member that inherits the collection that ends up selling the cards. If you come to the point where you feel that the value of the collection could be put to better use then please contact us. You have my word that you will be treated fairly and honestly and that we will pay top dollar for your collection.

    I look forward to hearing from you.

    by Dean Hanley

    Report this card

    Thank you for your report.

    This dialog will close automatically.