Willie Mays Baseball Cards


Willie Mays baseball cards are some of the most desired in the hobby. During the decades of the 1950s and 1960s, Willie Mays was arguably the best player in the game or at least in the NL.

The Say Hey Kid's rookie card is the 1951 Bowman #305.  Mays also has a couple of valuable cards issued the next year: 1952 Bowman #218 and his first Topps card 1952 Topps #261

What I always liked about Willie Mays baseball cards was that he was one of the few super stars that did not sign an exclusive contract and had both Bowman and Topps Baseball cards from 1952 to 1955.  

Willie Mays baseball cards in nice condition are often tough to find. The only reason that I can think of that makes his cards so condition sensitive, is that he was so popular with the kids when the cards were issued. It seemed that everyone wanted to handle his card.

The search below shows every Willie Mays baseball card now available along with prices and scans of the ACTUAL CARDS. At Dean's Cards, "What you see is what you get!" 

By Dean Hanley

Showing 1 to 100 of 169 products.

Page : 1 2 Next >>

Page Size:

Team is New York HALL-OF-FAME VARIATION
Qty
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$50.00
$48 after 5% discount
2
Good - 2
$35.00
2
San Francisco HALL-OF-FAME VARIATION
Qty
Very Good - 3
$45.00
1
Good - 2
$35.00
2
ROOKIE HALL-OF-FAME
Qty
PSA 3 - VG
$2,930
$2,344 after 20% discount
1
PSA 1 - POOR
$1,300
$1,040 after 20% discount
1
PSA 3 - VG
$770.00
$655 after 15% discount
1
Good - 2
$400.00
$360 after 10% discount
2
PSA 3 - VG
$2,080
$1,664 after 20% discount
2
BVG AUTOGRAPHED
$1,950
$1,560 after 20% discount
1
With Tab HALL-OF-FAME
Qty
Very Good - 3
$300.00
$270 after 10% discount
1
Fair - 1.5
$170.00
$153 after 10% discount
1
PSA 3.5 - VG+
$1,410
$1,128 after 20% discount
1
PSA 2.5 - GD+
$1,050
$840 after 20% discount
1
PSA 2 - GOOD
$900.00
$765 after 15% discount
2
PSA 1.5 - FAIR
$730.00
$621 after 15% discount
1
PSA 1.5 - FAIR
$730.00
$621 after 15% discount
1
PSA 1 - POOR
$590.00
$502 after 15% discount
1
PSA 7 - NM
$950.00
$808 after 15% discount
1
PSA 5 - EX
$375.00
$338 after 10% discount
1
PSA 4 - VG/EX
$250.00
$225 after 10% discount
2
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$200.00
$180 after 10% discount
1
Fair - 1.5
$100.00
$90 after 10% discount
1
Poor - 1
$80.00
$76 after 5% discount
1
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$950.00
$808 after 15% discount
1
PSA 2 - GOOD
$200.00
$180 after 10% discount
1
Good - 2
$165.00
$149 after 10% discount
1
Fair - 1.5
$130.00
$117 after 10% discount
2
With Tab HALL-OF-FAME
Qty
PSA 4 - VG/EX
$345.00
$311 after 10% discount
1
Fair - 1.5
$120.00
$108 after 10% discount
1
PSA 5 - EX
$250.00
$225 after 10% discount
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$160.00
$144 after 10% discount
2
Very Good - 3
$130.00
$117 after 10% discount
1
Good - 2
$85.00
$81 after 5% discount
4
Fair - 1.5
$70.00
$67 after 5% discount
2
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$1,040
$832 after 20% discount
1
Fair - 1.5
$155.00
$140 after 10% discount
1
No Tab HALL-OF-FAME
Qty
Near Mint - 7
$300.00
$270 after 10% discount
1
Good - 2
$50.00
$48 after 5% discount
2
With Tab HALL-OF-FAME
Qty
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$255.00
$230 after 10% discount
1
Gray Back HALL-OF-FAME
Qty
Excellent - 5
$335.00
$302 after 10% discount
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$200.00
$180 after 10% discount
2
Very Good - 3
$150.00
$135 after 10% discount
2
Good - 2
$125.00
$113 after 10% discount
2
Fair - 1.5
$100.00
$90 after 10% discount
1
Poor - 1
$85.00
$81 after 5% discount
1
White Back HALL-OF-FAME
Qty
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$230.00
$207 after 10% discount
1
Very Good - 3
$190.00
$171 after 10% discount
1
Good - 2
$180.00
$162 after 10% discount
1
PSA 7 - NM
$750.00
$638 after 15% discount
1
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$415.00
$374 after 10% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$160.00
$144 after 10% discount
4
Good - 2
$100.00
$90 after 10% discount
1
Fair - 1.5
$70.00
$67 after 5% discount
1
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$330.00
$297 after 10% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$165.00
$149 after 10% discount
2
Very Good - 3
$81.00
$77 after 5% discount
3
Good - 2
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
2
Fair - 1.5
$48.00
2
Poor - 1
$15.00
2
Excellent/Mint - 6
$72.00
$68 after 5% discount
5
Excellent - 5
$45.00
3
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$31.50
3
Very Good - 3
$22.50
3
Good - 2
$15.00
1
Fair - 1.5
$10.50
1
PSA 7 - NM
$210.00
$189 after 10% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$120.00
$108 after 10% discount
2
PSA 5 - EX
$81.00
$77 after 5% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$67.50
$64 after 5% discount
2
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$54.00
$51 after 5% discount
3
Very Good - 3
$37.50
6
PSA 8.5 - NM/MT+
$1,910
$1,528 after 20% discount
1
PSA 7 - NM
$440.00
$396 after 10% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$210.00
$189 after 10% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$150.00
$135 after 10% discount
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$110.00
$99 after 10% discount
2
Very Good - 3
$72.00
$68 after 5% discount
5
Good - 2
$48.00
5
Fair - 1.5
$38.00
3
PSA 7 - NM
$130.00
$117 after 10% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$70.00
$67 after 5% discount
2
Excellent - 5
$34.00
4
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$24.00
4
Very Good - 3
$18.00
3
Good - 2
$11.00
4
Fair - 1.5
$9.00
1
PSA 8 - NM/MT
$215.00
$194 after 10% discount
1
PSA 7 - NM
$145.00
$131 after 10% discount
2
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$86.50
$82 after 5% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$72.00
$68 after 5% discount
2
Excellent - 5
$45.00
3
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$40.00
2
Very Good - 3
$28.00
4
Good - 2
$20.00
2
Poor - 1
$10.00
1
PSA 8 - NM/MT
$500.00
$425 after 15% discount
1
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$160.00
$144 after 10% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$100.00
$90 after 10% discount
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$76.00
$72 after 5% discount
1
Very Good - 3
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
2
Good - 2
$40.00
2
Fair - 1.5
$28.00
1
Near Mint - 7
$55.00
$52 after 5% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$21.50
4
Excellent - 5
$13.00
2
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$6.50
5
Very Good - 3
$4.50
6
Good - 2
$4.00
1
Fair - 1.5
$2.80
2
Poor - 1
$2.00
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$95.00
$90 after 5% discount
2
Very Good - 3
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
5
Good - 2
$42.50
4
Excellent - 5
$80.00
$76 after 5% discount
1
PSA 4 - VG/EX
$65.00
$62 after 5% discount
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$54.00
$51 after 5% discount
2
Good - 2
$30.00
2
Excellent/Mint - 6
$22.50
4
Excellent - 5
$13.00
6
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$9.75
5
Very Good - 3
$7.50
4
Good - 2
$5.50
3
Fair - 1.5
$4.25
1
SGC 7.5 - NM+
$220.00
$198 after 10% discount
1
PSA 7 - NM
$215.00
$194 after 10% discount
2
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$92.50
$88 after 5% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$77.00
$73 after 5% discount
4
Excellent - 5
$45.00
4
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$48.00
2
Very Good - 3
$36.00
3
Good - 2
$22.50
3
Fair - 1.5
$18.00
2
PSA 7 - NM
$145.00
$131 after 10% discount
2
Excellent/Mint - 6
$75.00
$71 after 5% discount
2
Excellent - 5
$55.00
$52 after 5% discount
2
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$40.00
2
Very Good - 3
$30.00
1
Good - 2
$20.00
1
Fair - 1.5
$14.00
1
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$200.00
$180 after 10% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$165.00
$149 after 10% discount
1
PSA 5 - EX
$145.00
$131 after 10% discount
1
Good - 2
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
1
Ordered from Company HALL-OF-FAME
Qty
Excellent - 5
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
2
Handcut from Cereal Box HALL-OF-FAME
Qty
Excellent - 5
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
2
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$48.00
1
Very Good - 3
$32.00
5
Good - 2
$19.00
6
Fair - 1.5
$17.00
1
Near Mint/Mint - 8
$45.00
3
Near Mint - 7
$29.00
3
Excellent/Mint - 6
$20.00
1
Excellent - 5
$13.00
1
Very Good - 3
$8.00
2
Good - 2
$5.00
1
Near Mint - 7
$29.00
3
Excellent/Mint - 6
$20.00
1
Excellent - 5
$13.00
1
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$205.00
$185 after 10% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$170.00
$153 after 10% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$120.00
$108 after 10% discount
3
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$65.00
$62 after 5% discount
6
Very Good - 3
$59.50
$57 after 5% discount
5
Good - 2
$44.00
5
PSA 7 - NM
$49.50
1
Near Mint - 7
$41.50
3
Excellent/Mint - 6
$20.00
7
Excellent - 5
$9.50
7
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$7.25
6
Very Good - 3
$4.00
9
Good - 2
$5.00
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$230.00
$207 after 10% discount
1
SGC 5.5 - EX+
$195.00
$176 after 10% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$125.00
$113 after 10% discount
3
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$80.00
$76 after 5% discount
5
Very Good - 3
$67.50
$64 after 5% discount
3
Good - 2
$47.00
4
Excellent/Mint - 6
$63.00
$60 after 5% discount
3
Excellent - 5
$45.00
2
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$29.50
3
Very Good - 3
$25.00
2
Excellent/Mint - 6
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
2
Excellent - 5
$30.00
2
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$21.50
3
Very Good - 3
$13.00
6
Good - 2
$7.75
6
Fair - 1.5
$8.50
1
Poor - 1
$6.00
1
Excellent - 5
$35.00
1
Near Mint - 7
$55.00
$52 after 5% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$40.00
1
Near Mint - 7
$90.00
$86 after 5% discount
1
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$40.00
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$32.00
4
Excellent - 5
$16.00
5
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$16.00
2
Poor - 1
$4.00
1
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$42.00
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$30.00
6
Excellent - 5
$15.00
7
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$14.50
4
Very Good - 3
$14.50
3
Good - 2
$10.00
1
PSA 6.5 - EX/MT+
$275.00
$248 after 10% discount
1
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$220.00
$198 after 10% discount
1
Very Good - 3
$90.00
$86 after 5% discount
2
Good - 2
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
2
Excellent - 5
$45.00
1
Excellent - 5
$110.00
$99 after 10% discount
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$80.00
$76 after 5% discount
1
Very Good - 3
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
2
Good - 2
$28.00
7
Good - 2
$15.00
1
Excellent - 5
$150.00
$135 after 10% discount
1
Very Good - 3
$85.00
$81 after 5% discount
4
Good - 2
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
2
Near Mint - 7
$80.00
$76 after 5% discount
2
Excellent/Mint - 6
$40.50
3
Excellent - 5
$15.00
9
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$13.00
8
Excellent/Mint - 6
$155.00
$140 after 10% discount
2
Excellent - 5
$75.00
$71 after 5% discount
6
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$63.00
$60 after 5% discount
3
Very Good - 3
$50.00
$48 after 5% discount
2
Good - 2
$28.00
4
Fair - 1.5
$23.00
2
Excellent/Mint - 6
$42.50
4
Excellent - 5
$33.00
2
Very Good - 3
$16.00
5
Good - 2
$11.50
3
Fair - 1.5
$9.50
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$125.00
$113 after 10% discount
2
Excellent - 5
$68.00
$65 after 5% discount
4
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$50.50
$48 after 5% discount
3
Very Good - 3
$40.00
1
SHORT-PRINT HALL-OF-FAME
Qty
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$125.00
$113 after 10% discount
1
HALL-OF-FAME
Qty
Very Good - 3
$15.00
4
Excellent/Mint - 6
$27.00
5
Excellent - 5
$19.00
4
PSA 2 - GOOD
$720.00
$612 after 15% discount
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$310.00
$279 after 10% discount
1
PSA 8 - NM/MT
$215.00
$194 after 10% discount
1
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$55.00
$52 after 5% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$45.00
1
Excellent - 5
$30.00
2
Very Good - 3
$14.50
3
Good - 2
$10.00
2
Excellent/Mint - 6
$9.75
6
Excellent - 5
$4.25
7
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$3.50
5
Very Good - 3
$3.25
3
PSA 7 - NM
$440.00
$396 after 10% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$175.00
$158 after 10% discount
2
Excellent - 5
$125.00
$113 after 10% discount
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$89.00
$85 after 5% discount
1
Very Good - 3
$58.50
$56 after 5% discount
3
Good - 2
$36.00
3
Fair - 1.5
$28.00
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$65.00
$62 after 5% discount
2
Excellent - 5
$26.50
5
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$20.00
5
Very Good - 3
$17.00
4
Good - 2
$12.00
2
Fair - 1.5
$8.50
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$70.00
$67 after 5% discount
4
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$40.00
1
Very Good - 3
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$40.00
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$120.00
$108 after 10% discount
2
Very Good - 3
$40.00
10
Good - 2
$32.50
6
Fair - 1.5
$26.50
4
Poor - 1
$25.00
1
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$160.00
$144 after 10% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$135.00
$122 after 10% discount
2
Excellent - 5
$81.00
$77 after 5% discount
3
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$66.00
$63 after 5% discount
2
Very Good - 3
$50.00
$48 after 5% discount
2
Good - 2
$33.00
2
Fair - 1.5
$23.00
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$26.00
6
Excellent - 5
$12.00
7
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$11.50
4
Very Good - 3
$7.50
4
Good - 2
$6.00
2
Excellent/Mint - 6
$30.00
2
Excellent - 5
$9.75
6
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$7.50
5
Very Good - 3
$5.50
5
Good - 2
$5.00
2
Fair - 1.5
$3.50
2
Excellent/Mint - 6
$45.00
1
Good - 2
$300.00
$270 after 10% discount
1
Very Good - 3
$120.00
$108 after 10% discount
1
214 is Dick Kelley & Mays has No Neck CORRECT HALL-OF-FAME VARIATION
Qty
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$5.50
2
Very Good - 3
$4.00
1
Good - 2
$2.25
3
Fair - 1.5 Marked
$1.05
4
Poor - 1 Marked
$0.65
5
214 is Tom Kelley & Mays neck is shown ERROR HALL-OF-FAME VARIATION
Qty
PSA 8 - NM/MT
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$13.00
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$8.50
4
Very Good - 3
$6.00
4
Good - 2
$3.75
4
Fair - 1.5 Marked
$1.75
5
Poor - 1 Marked
$0.95
4
PSA 7 - NM
$230.00
$207 after 10% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$110.00
$99 after 10% discount
3
Excellent - 5
$80.00
$76 after 5% discount
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$59.00
$56 after 5% discount
2
Very Good - 3
$34.00
6
Poor - 1
$10.00
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$29.50
3
Excellent - 5
$17.00
4
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$16.00
2
Very Good - 3
$13.00
1
Good - 2
$7.00
2
Poor - 1
$3.00
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$55.00
$52 after 5% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$35.00
2
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$26.00
2
Very Good - 3
$18.00
3
Near Mint - 7
$100.00
$90 after 10% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$26.00
8
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$31.00
2
Very Good - 3
$22.50
3
Good - 2
$12.50
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$125.00
$113 after 10% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$67.50
$64 after 5% discount
3
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
2
Very Good - 3
$40.00
5
Good - 2
$30.00
1
Poor - 1
$15.00
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$130.00
$117 after 10% discount
1
Good - 2
$80.00
$76 after 5% discount
1
Poor - 1
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
1
Near Mint - 7
$50.00
$48 after 5% discount
2
Excellent/Mint - 6
$33.00
2
Excellent - 5
$16.00
2
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$12.50
1
Very Good - 3
$8.50
4
Fair - 1.5
$4.25
1
PSA 7 - NM
$250.00
$225 after 10% discount
1
SGC 6 - EX/MT
$155.00
$140 after 10% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$72.00
$68 after 5% discount
3
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$47.50
4
Very Good - 3
$36.00
3
Good - 2
$25.00
1
Poor - 1
$12.50
2
Near Mint - 7
$90.00
$86 after 5% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$45.00
2
Excellent - 5
$19.00
4
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$13.00
4
Very Good - 3
$6.00
14
Good - 2
$4.75
7
Fair - 1.5
$5.50
1
PSA 6.5 - EX/MT+
$215.00
$194 after 10% discount
1
Very Good - 3
$80.00
$76 after 5% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$45.00
1
PSA 8 - NM/MT
$280.00
$252 after 10% discount
2
PSA 6 - EX/MT
$130.00
$117 after 10% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$110.00
$99 after 10% discount
1
PSA 5 - EX
$78.00
$74 after 5% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$65.00
$62 after 5% discount
1
Very Good - 3
$40.00
1
Good - 2
$25.00
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
2
Excellent - 5
$34.00
4
Good - 2
$20.00
2
Excellent/Mint - 6
$16.00
1
Excellent - 5
$10.00
1
Very Good - 3
$6.00
1
Good - 2
$4.00
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$125.00
$113 after 10% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$90.00
$86 after 5% discount
2
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
1
Very Good - 3
$36.00
5
Good - 2
$30.00
1
Fair - 1.5
$21.00
2
HALL-OF-FAME
Qty
Excellent/Mint - 6
$50.00
$48 after 5% discount
1
Very Good - 3
$30.00
2
Good - 2
$20.00
1
PSA 8 - NM/MT
$155.00
$140 after 10% discount
2
Near Mint - 7
$60.00
$57 after 5% discount
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$26.50
6
Excellent - 5
$18.00
1
Near Mint - 7
$50.00
$48 after 5% discount
2
Excellent/Mint - 6
$8.75
8
Excellent - 5
$4.00
13
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$4.75
4
Very Good - 3
$2.50
15
Good - 2
$2.70
3
PSA 7 - NM
$120.00
$108 after 10% discount
1
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$31.00
1
Very Good - 3
$25.00
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$45.00
1
Very Good - 3
$18.00
1
Lifetime RBI reads 1856 HALL-OF-FAME CORRECT VARIATION
Qty
Near Mint - 7
$35.00
1
PSA 8 - NM/MT
$200.00
$180 after 10% discount
1
Excellent - 5
$15.00
9
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$18.00
2
Very Good - 3
$8.50
8
Good - 2
$7.25
3
Excellent/Mint - 6
$35.00
7
Excellent - 5
$28.00
4
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$25.00
1
Very Good - 3
$20.00
2
Good - 2
$13.00
1
Near Mint/Mint - 8
$40.00
2
Near Mint - 7
$25.00
1
Excellent/Mint - 6
$9.00
6
Excellent - 5
$5.50
3
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$4.75
1
Very Good - 3
$4.00
1

Page : 1 2 Next >>

Report this card

Thank you for your report.

This dialog will close automatically.