Baseball Cards

Pre-War 1948 to 1959 1960s 1970s 1980s to Present

Football Cards

1930s to 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s to Present

Other Cards

Basketball Cards Soccer Cards Hockey Cards Boxing Cards Non-Sports Cards Reprint Cards Autographs

Sets

Complete Sets Starter & Near Sets Team Sets & Lots Reprint Sets

Magazines

Sports Illustrated (SI) The Sporting News (TSN) Sports Magazines MLB Team Publications Programs & Tickets

More

Wax Packs & Wrappers Gift Certificates

Baseball Cards

Pre-War 1948 to 1959 1960s 1970s 1980s to Present

Football Cards

1930s to 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s to Present

Other Cards

Basketball Cards Soccer Cards Hockey Cards Boxing Cards Non-Sports Cards Reprint Cards Autographs

Sets

Complete Sets Starter & Near Sets Team Sets & Lots Reprint Sets

Magazines

Sports Illustrated (SI) The Sporting News (TSN) Sports Magazines MLB Team Publications Programs & Score Cards

More

Wax Packs & Wrappers Gift Certificates

Allie Reynolds

Allie Pierce Reynolds (February 10, 1917 – December 26, 1994) was an American professional baseball pitcher in Major League Baseball (MLB). Reynolds pitched in MLB for the Cleveland Indians (1942–1946) and New York Yankees (1947–1954). A member of the Creek nation, Reynolds was nicknamed "Superchief".

Reynolds attended Capitol Hill High School and the Oklahoma Agricultural & Mechanical College (A&M), where he was a multi-sport athlete. Henry Iba, baseball coach of the Oklahoma A&M baseball team, discovered Reynolds while he was practicing his javelin throws. After excelling at baseball and American football at Oklahoma A&M, Reynolds chose to turn professional in baseball.

In his MLB career, Reynolds had a 182–107 win–loss record, 3.30 earned run average, and 1,423 strikeouts. Reynolds was a six-time MLB All-Star (1945, 1949, 1950, 1952, 1953, 1954) and six-time World Series champion (1947, 1949, 1950, 1951, 1952, 1953). He won the Hickok Belt in 1951 as the top American professional athlete of the year. He has also received consideration for induction into the National Baseball Hall of Fame, though he has not been elected.

Hide Sets

Showing 1 to 23 of 23 products.

Page Size: 100 1000

Page : 1

#14 Allie Reynolds (ROOKIE)

View All

1948 Bowman Baseball Cards

Yankees

Qty

View All

PSA 6.5 - EX/MT+

$370

$333 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint+ - 6.5

$275

$248 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

PSA 6 - EX/MT

$305

$275 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$66.00

$63 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$45.00

1

View Close + Cart

#114 Allie Reynolds

View All

1949 Bowman Baseball

Yankees

Qty

View All

PSA 4 - VG/EX

$145

$131 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$110

$99 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$76.00

$72 after 5% discount

2

View Close + Cart

#138 Allie Reynolds

View All

1950 Bowman Baseball

Yankees

Qty

View All

PSA 7 - NM

$275

$248 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$52.50

$50 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$23.00

1

View Close + Cart

#109 Allie Reynolds

View All

1951 Bowman Baseball

Yankees

Qty

View All

Excellent - 5

$115

$104 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$96.00

$91 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Good+ - 2.5

$63.00

$60 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$60.00

$57 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

#6 Allie Reynolds

View All

1951 Topps Red Back

Yankees

Qty

View All

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$63.50

$60 after 5% discount

2

View Close + Cart

3-3 - Allie Reynolds

View All

Qty

View All

PSA 7 - NM

$195

$176 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$51.00

$48 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$27.50

1

View Close + Cart

#67 Allie Reynolds

View All

1952 Topps Baseball Cards

Yankees

Qty

View All

PSA 5 - EX

$305

$275 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

PSA 4 - VG/EX

$230

$207 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$120

$108 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$82.00

$78 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$35.50

1

View Close + Cart

#68 Allie Reynolds

View All

1953 Bowman Baseball

Yankees

Qty

View All

PSA 6 - EX/MT

$245

$221 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$90.00

$86 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good+ - 3.5

$72.00

$68 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$60.00

$57 after 5% discount

2

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$30.00

2

View Close + Cart

Poor - 1

$20.00

2

View Close + Cart

Authentic

$10.00

1

View Close + Cart

#141 Allie Reynolds (DOUBLE-PRINT)

View All

1953 Topps Baseball Cards

Yankees

Qty

View All

PSA 6.5 - EX/MT+

$340

$306 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

PSA 6 - EX/MT

$270

$243 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$105

$95 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$68.00

$65 after 5% discount

2

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$34.00

4

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$23.00

4

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$15.00

5

View Close + Cart

#113 Allie Reynolds

View All

1954 Bowman Baseball Cards

Yankees

Qty

View All

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$69.00

$66 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$61.00

$58 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$26.50

2

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$15.00

2

View Close + Cart

Poor - 1

$8.50

3

View Close + Cart

Authentic

$4.75

1

View Close + Cart

#201 Allie Reynolds

View All

1955 Bowman Baseball Cards

Yankees

Qty

View All

Near Mint - 7

$140

$126 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$29.00

3

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$13.00

4

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$9.50

3

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$7.75

2

View Close + Cart

#16 Allie Reynolds

View All

1955 Armour Coins

Yankees

Qty

View All

Excellent - 5

$53.00

$50 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

#69 Allie Reynolds

View All

1961 Fleer Baseball

Yankees

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$28.50

3

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint+ - 6.5

$16.00

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$10.00

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good+ - 3.5

$5.25

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$4.75

1

View Close + Cart

#46 1949 Yankees vs. Dodgers - Allie Reynolds / Preacher Roe

View All

1970 Fleer World Series

Yankees Dodgers

Qty

View All

PSA 8 - NM/MT

$56.00

$53 after 5% discount

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$3.75

3

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$2.55

1

View Close + Cart

#41 Allie Reynolds

View All

1988 Pacific Legends I Baseball Cards

Yankees

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$1.00

2

View Close + Cart

#185 Allie Reynolds

View All

1979 TCMA 50s Baseball Cards

Yankees

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$0.99

6

View Close + Cart

#67 Allie Reynolds

View All

1952 Topps Reprint

Yankees

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$6.00

2

View Close + Cart

#141 Allie Reynolds

View All

1953 Topps Archives / Reprint

Yankees

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$12.00

1

View Close + Cart

Allie Reynolds

View All

1947 Tip Top Bread Reprints

Yankees

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$1.85

2

View Close + Cart

#14 Allie Reynolds (ROOKIE)

View All

1948 Bowman Reprint

Yankees

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$3.25

2

View Close + Cart

#114 Allie Reynolds

View All

1949 Bowman Reprint

Yankees

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$0.99

4

View Close + Cart

#138 Allie Reynolds

View All

1950 Bowman Reprint

Yankees

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$0.99

4

View Close + Cart

#68 Allie Reynolds

View All

1953 Bowman Color Reprint

Yankees

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$0.99

4

View Close + Cart

Page : 1

Dean's Cards® is a registered trademark of Dean's Cards, LLC. 2026

Thank you for your report.

This dialog will close automatically.

Please consider
leaving a review