Baseball Cards

Pre-War 1948 to 1959 1960s 1970s 1980s to Present

Football Cards

1930s to 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s to Present

Other Cards

Basketball Cards Soccer Cards Hockey Cards Boxing Cards Non-Sports Cards Reprint Cards Autographs

Sets

Complete Sets Starter & Near Sets Team Sets & Lots Reprint Sets

Magazines

Sports Illustrated (SI) The Sporting News (TSN) Sports Magazines MLB Team Publications Programs & Tickets

More

Wax Packs & Wrappers Gift Certificates

Baseball Cards

Pre-War 1948 to 1959 1960s 1970s 1980s to Present

Football Cards

1930s to 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s to Present

Other Cards

Basketball Cards Soccer Cards Hockey Cards Boxing Cards Non-Sports Cards Reprint Cards Autographs

Sets

Complete Sets Starter & Near Sets Team Sets & Lots Reprint Sets

Magazines

Sports Illustrated (SI) The Sporting News (TSN) Sports Magazines MLB Team Publications Programs & Score Cards

More

Wax Packs & Wrappers Gift Certificates

Shop Reprint Sets!

View all Pre-War Complete Sets

Check out our best deals!

T207 Reprint Set

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

The 1887 Old Judge baseball card set consists of somewhere around 500 unnumbered cards, that measure approximately 1-7/16" by 2-1/2". Also known as N172 cards, they were included inside packs of Old Judge Cigarettes between 1887 and 1890, and can be easily recognized by "Goodwin & Co. New York" on the base of each card.

The "Browns Champions" cards from the N172 set refer to the 13 players from the 1886 St. Louis Browns and is popular with collectors due to the subject matter and attractive pictures. The harder Old Judge baseball cards to find are the "Spotted Tie" cards, which show the players, from the 1887 New York Mets, wearing the same polka dot tie.

The N172 Old Judge Baseball Card Set contains 25 hall-of-famers, including: Cap Anson, Jacob Beckley, Dan Brouthers, Charles Comiskey, Ed Delehanty, Hugh Duffy, Buck Ewing, Clark Griffith, Billy Hamilton, Mike Kelly, Connie Mack, Kid Nichols, Wilbert Robinson & Harry Wright.

CLICK HERE if you want to sell your 1887-90 Old Judge (N172) cards.

Hide Sets

Showing 1 to 93 of 93 products.

Page Size: 100 1000

Page : 1

1887-90 Old Judge N172 25 Card Starter Set

View All + Want

Qty

View All + Want

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$18,160

$14,528 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good+ - 3.5

$15,710

$12,568 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

1887-90 Old Judge N172 50 Card Starter Set

View All + Want

Qty

View All + Want

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$35,060

$28,048 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good+ - 3.5

$31,800

$25,440 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Ed Andrews

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$790

$672 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Tug Arundel

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$520

$442 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 2.5 - GD+

$370

$333 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Charles Bastian

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 2 - GOOD

$460

$414 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

William Blair

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 5 - EX

$1,240

$992 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Ned Bligh

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 3 - VG

$660

$561 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Honest John Boyle

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 2.5 - GD+

$910

$774 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Handsome Henry Boyle

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$500

$425 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

California Cal Brown

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$800

$680 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Dick Buckley

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 5 - EX

$890

$757 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+

$780

$663 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

George Watch Burnham (MANAGER)

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$690

$587 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Dad Clarke

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 3 - VG

$820

$697 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Jack Clements

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$770

$655 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 3 - VG

$610

$519 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

PSA 2 - GOOD

$540

$459 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Monk Cline

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$690

$587 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Bill Collins

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3.5 - VG+

$1,100

$880 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 2 - GOOD

$850

$723 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 1 - POOR

$610

$519 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Billy Crowell

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$680

$578 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Tacks Curtis

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 2.5 - GD+

$510

$434 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Edward Dailey

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$690

$587 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Con Daley

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$640

$544 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

PSA 2.5 - GD+

$720

$612 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Dell Darling

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Chicago

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 5 - EX

$1,030

$824 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Pat Dealey

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 1.5 - FAIR

$450

$405 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Pat Deasley

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 5 - EX

$700

$595 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+

$630

$536 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 3 - VG

$480

$432 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Mike Dorgan

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 2 (MC) - GOOD

$400

$360 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Hugh Duffy (HALL-OF-FAME)

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 1.5 - FAIR

$1,280

$1,024 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Jay Faatz

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 3 - VG

$820

$697 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Bill Farmer

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 4 - VG/EX

$870

$740 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 2 - GOOD

$405

$365 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Sidney Farrar

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Phillies

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 3.5 - VG+

$670

$570 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Jack Moose Farrell

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 1.5 - FAIR

$405

$365 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Silver Flint

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 5 - EX

$1,060

$848 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Dave Foutz

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Browns

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$760

$646 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Julie Freeman

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 5 - EX

$1,010

$808 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Charlie Getzein

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$690

$587 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Robert Gilks

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 4.5 - VG/EX+

$880

$748 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 3 - VG

$500

$425 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Pete Gillespie

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$680

$578 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Michael Goodfellow

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 4 - VG/EX

$910

$774 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 3 - VG

$630

$536 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

George Gore

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3.5 - VG+

$690

$587 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 3 - VG

$610

$519 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Clark Griffith (HALL-OF-FAME)

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 1 (MK) - POOR

$920

$782 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Henry Gruber

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 2 - GOOD

$460

$414 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Thomas Gunning

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 2 - GOOD

$500

$425 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Bill Hallman

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$780

$663 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Gil Hatfield

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

New York

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 3 - VG

$670

$570 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Moxie Hengle

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 2.5 - GD+

$600

$510 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

William Holbert

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 3 - VG

$810

$689 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Charles Hoover

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$690

$587 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Pete Hotaling

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$800

$680 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Nat Hudson

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Browns

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 1.5 - FAIR

$315

$284 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Richard Johnston

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 7 - NM

$1,360

$1,088 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Tim Keefe (HALL-OF-FAME)

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 5 - EX

$5,560

$4,448 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

August Kloff

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3.5 - VG+

$730

$621 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Bill Krieg

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+

$880

$748 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

PSA 4 - VG/EX

$920

$782 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Herman Germany Long

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$770

$655 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Charles Lefty Marr

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$940

$799 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Mike Mattimore

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 4 - VG/EX

$860

$731 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

PSA 2.5 - GD+

$640

$544 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 2.5 - GD+

$530

$451 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Albert Maul

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 2.5 - GD+

$730

$621 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

PSA 2 - GOOD

$710

$604 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Albert Mays

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 2.5 - GD+

$590

$502 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

James Deacon McGuire

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$1,030

$824 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

George Doggie Miller

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Pirates

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$940

$799 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

PSA 3 - VG

$840

$714 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

E.L. Mills

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 2.5 - GD+

$760

$646 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Ed Morris

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 2 - GOOD

$460

$414 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Joseph Mulvey

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$460

$414 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

P.L. Murphy

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

Good - 2

$520

$442 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Al Cod Myers

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+

$1,100

$880 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Thomas Nagle

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 2.5 - GD+

$670

$570 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Billy Nash

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+

$1,220

$976 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Billy O'Brien

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 1.5 - FAIR

$370

$333 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Fred Pfeffer

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$820

$697 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

George Pinkney

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3.5 - VG+

$790

$672 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Henry Porter

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 2.5 - GD+

$490

$441 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Shorty Radford

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 5 - EX

$890

$757 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 2 - GOOD

$500

$425 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Danny Richardson

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 4 - VG/EX

$910

$774 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 1.5 - FAIR

$310

$279 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Yank Robinson

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 2 - GOOD

$460

$414 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Jack Rowe

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+

$990

$842 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Jumbo Schoeneck

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$710

$604 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Emmett Seery

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$850

$723 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Otto Schomberg

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 5 - EX

$1,220

$976 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 3 - VG

$710

$604 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Lev Shreve

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 5 - EX

$1,130

$904 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 3 - VG

$660

$561 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Michael Slattery

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 5 - EX

$840

$714 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$680

$578 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Elmer Smith

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3.5 - VG+

$880

$748 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Bill Sowders

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 5 - EX

$940

$799 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

John Sowders

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 5 - EX

$1,870

$1,496 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Ed Sproat

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 5 - EX

$1,250

$1,000 after 20% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Harry Staley

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$800

$680 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

John Cub Stricker

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$680

$578 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Cy Sutcliffe

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+

$680

$578 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Patsy Tebeau

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$850

$723 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Silent Mike Tiernan

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 3 - VG

$850

$723 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Stephen Toole

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 4 - VG/EX

$960

$816 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

William Tuckerman

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 4 - VG/EX

$710

$604 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Ned Williamson

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

SGC 3 - VG

$850

$723 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Samuel Wise

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 3 - VG

$820

$697 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

George Dandy Wood

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 3 - VG

$800

$680 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Peter Wood

View All + Want

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

Qty

View All + Want

PSA 4 - VG/EX

$810

$689 after 15% discount

1

View Close + Cart

SGC 3 - VG

$460

$414 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Page : 1

Dean's Cards® is a registered trademark of Dean's Cards, LLC. 2025

Thank you for your report.

This dialog will close automatically.

Please consider
leaving a review