1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

1887-90 Old Judge (N172)

The 1887 Old Judge baseball card set consists of somewhere around 500 unnumbered cards, that measure approximately 1-7/16" by 2-1/2".  Also known as N172 cards, they were included inside packs of Old Judge Cigarettes between 1887 and 1890, and can be easily recognized by "Goodwin & Co. New York" on the base of each card.

The "Browns Champions" cards from the N172 set refer to the 13 players from the 1886 St. Louis Browns and is popular with collectors due to the subject matter and attractive pictures.  The harder Old Judge baseball cards to find are the "Spotted Tie" cards, which show the players, from the 1887 New York Mets, wearing the same polka dot tie.

The N172 Old Judge Baseball Card Set contains 25 hall-of-famers, including: Cap Anson, Jacob Beckley, Dan Brouthers, Charles Comiskey, Ed Delehanty, Hugh Duffy, Buck Ewing, Clark Griffith, Billy Hamilton, Mike Kelly, Connie Mack, Kid Nichols, Wilbert Robinson & Harry Wright.

CLICK HERE if you want to sell your 1887-90 Old Judge (N172) cards.

1887-90 Old Judge N172 25 Card Starter Set
View All + Want
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
 $18,010 
$14,408 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good+ - 3.5
 $15,640 
$12,512 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
1887-90 Old Judge N172 50 Card Starter Set
View All + Want
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
 $35,220 
$28,176 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good+ - 3.5
 $31,410 
$25,128 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Ed Andrews
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $790 
$672 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Tug Arundel
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $520 
$442 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 2.5 - GD+
 $345 
$311 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Charles Bastian
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 2 - GOOD
 $460 
$414 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
William Blair
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 5 - EX
 $1,240 
$992 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Ned Bligh
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 3 - VG
 $550 
$468 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Honest John Boyle
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 2.5 - GD+
 $910 
$774 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Handsome Henry Boyle
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $500 
$425 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Timothy Brosnan
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 1.5 - FAIR
 $310 
$279 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Dan Brouthers (HALL-OF-FAME)
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $2,850 
$2,280 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
California Cal Brown
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $800 
$680 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 2 - GOOD
 $385 
$347 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Dick Buckley
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 5 - EX
 $890 
$757 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+
 $780 
$663 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
George Watch Burnham (MANAGER)
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $690 
$587 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Dad Clarke
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 3 - VG
 $820 
$697 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Jack Clements
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $770 
$655 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 3 - VG
 $610 
$519 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
PSA 2 - GOOD
 $495 
$446 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 1.5 - FAIR
 $330 
$297 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Monk Cline
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $690 
$587 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Bill Collins
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3.5 - VG+
 $1,100 
$880 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 2 - GOOD
 $850 
$723 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 1 - POOR
 $530 
$451 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Sam Crane
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 2.5 - GD+
 $440 
$396 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Billy Crowell
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $680 
$578 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Tacks Curtis
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 2.5 - GD+
 $510 
$434 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Edward Dailey
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $690 
$587 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Con Daley
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $640 
$544 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
PSA 2.5 - GD+
 $660 
$561 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Dell Darling
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Chicago
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 5 - EX
 $1,030 
$824 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Pat Dealey
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 1.5 - FAIR
 $450 
$405 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Pat Deasley
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 5 - EX
 $700 
$595 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+
 $630 
$536 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 3 - VG
 $480 
$432 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Mike Dorgan
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 2 (MC) - GOOD
 $400 
$360 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Hugh Duffy (HALL-OF-FAME)
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 1.5 - FAIR
 $1,280 
$1,024 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Jay Faatz
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 3 - VG
 $820 
$697 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Bill Farmer
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 4 - VG/EX
 $870 
$740 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 2 - GOOD
 $405 
$365 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Sidney Farrar
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Phillies
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 3.5 - VG+
 $670 
$570 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Jack Moose Farrell
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 1.5 - FAIR
 $405 
$365 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Silver Flint
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 5 - EX
 $1,060 
$848 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Dave Foutz
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Browns
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $690 
$587 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Julie Freeman
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 5 - EX
 $1,010 
$808 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Charlie Getzein
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $690 
$587 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Robert Gilks
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 4.5 - VG/EX+
 $880 
$748 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 3 - VG
 $500 
$425 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Pete Gillespie
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $680 
$578 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Michael Goodfellow
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 4 - VG/EX
 $910 
$774 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 3 - VG
 $630 
$536 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
George Gore
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3.5 - VG+
 $690 
$587 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 3 - VG
 $610 
$519 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Clark Griffith (HALL-OF-FAME)
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 1 (MK) - POOR
 $920 
$782 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Henry Gruber
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 2 - GOOD
 $460 
$414 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Thomas Gunning
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 2 - GOOD
 $500 
$425 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Bill Hallman
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $780 
$663 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Gil Hatfield
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
New York
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 3 - VG
 $670 
$570 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Moxie Hengle
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 2.5 - GD+
 $600 
$510 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
William Holbert
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 3 - VG
 $810 
$689 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Charles Hoover
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $690 
$587 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Pete Hotaling
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $800 
$680 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Nat Hudson
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Browns
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 1.5 - FAIR
 $315 
$284 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Richard Johnston
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 7 - NM
 $1,240 
$992 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Tim Keefe (HALL-OF-FAME)
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 5 - EX
 $5,560 
$4,448 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
August Kloff
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3.5 - VG+
 $730 
$621 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Bill Krieg
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+
 $880 
$748 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
PSA 4 - VG/EX
 $920 
$782 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Herman Germany Long
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $770 
$655 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Charles Lefty Marr
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $940 
$799 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Mike Mattimore
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 4 - VG/EX
 $860 
$731 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
PSA 2.5 - GD+
 $610 
$519 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 2.5 - GD+
 $510 
$434 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Albert Maul
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 2.5 - GD+
 $730 
$621 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
PSA 2 - GOOD
 $710 
$604 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Albert Mays
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 2.5 - GD+
 $590 
$502 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
James Deacon McGuire
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $1,030 
$824 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
George Doggie Miller
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Pirates
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $940 
$799 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
PSA 3 - VG
 $840 
$714 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
E.L. Mills
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 2.5 - GD+
 $760 
$646 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Ed Morris
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 2 - GOOD
 $460 
$414 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Joseph Mulvey
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $460 
$414 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
P.L. Murphy
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
Good - 2
 $520 
$442 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Al Cod Myers
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+
 $1,100 
$880 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Thomas Nagle
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 2.5 - GD+
 $670 
$570 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Billy Nash
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+
 $1,220 
$976 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Billy O'Brien
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 1.5 - FAIR
 $370 
$333 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Fred Pfeffer
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $660 
$561 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
George Pinkney
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3.5 - VG+
 $720 
$612 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Henry Porter
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 2.5 - GD+
 $445 
$401 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Shorty Radford
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 5 - EX
 $890 
$757 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 2 - GOOD
 $500 
$425 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Danny Richardson
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 4 - VG/EX
 $910 
$774 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 1.5 - FAIR
 $310 
$279 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Yank Robinson
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 2 - GOOD
 $460 
$414 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Jack Rowe
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+
 $990 
$842 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Jumbo Schoeneck
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $710 
$604 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Emmett Seery
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $850 
$723 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Otto Schomberg
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 5 - EX
 $1,220 
$976 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 3 - VG
 $710 
$604 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Lev Shreve
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 5 - EX
 $1,130 
$904 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 3 - VG
 $660 
$561 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Michael Slattery
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 5 - EX
 $840 
$714 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $680 
$578 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Elmer Smith
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3.5 - VG+
 $880 
$748 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Bill Sowders
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 5 - EX
 $940 
$799 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
John Sowders
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 5 - EX
 $1,030 
$824 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Ed Sproat
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 5 - EX
 $1,250 
$1,000 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Harry Staley
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $800 
$680 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
John Cub Stricker
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $680 
$578 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Cy Sutcliffe
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4.5 - VG/EX+
 $610 
$519 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Patsy Tebeau
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $850 
$723 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Silent Mike Tiernan
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 3 - VG
 $850 
$723 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Stephen Toole
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 4 - VG/EX
 $960 
$816 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
William Tuckerman
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 4 - VG/EX
 $710 
$604 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Ned Williamson
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $850 
$723 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Samuel Wise
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 3 - VG
 $820 
$697 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
George Dandy Wood
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 3 - VG
 $730 
$621 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Peter Wood
View All + Want
1887-90 Old Judge (N172)
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 4 - VG/EX
 $810 
$689 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 3 - VG
 $460 
$414 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart

Page : 1

Dean's Cards® is a registered trademark of Dean's Cards, LLC. 2025

Report this card

Thank you for your report.

This dialog will close automatically.

Add To Cart Report
Please consider
leaving a review