1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards

The 1909 E-91 B American Caramel set contains 33 cards featuring players from Chicago, New York, and Philadelphia.  This set is very similar to the E91-A set in that it contains players from the same 3 teams, with the other set, E91-C featuring players from Boston, Pittsburgh, and Washington.  A unique note about these 3 sets was that the same artwork was used for different players across all sets, making it impossible to identify the card from the image alone.

This set was a release from the American Caramel Company and made a good alternative for younger collectors who couldn't collect baseball cards from cigarette products, such as the popular T206 cards from the same years.

CLICK HERE if you want to sell your 1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards.

Jack Barry (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Athletics
Qty
View All + Want
Poor - 1
 $135 
$122 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Chief Bender (HALL-OF-FAME Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 2 - GOOD
 $640 
$544 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Al Bridwell (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Qty
View All + Want
Fair - 1.5
 $160 
$144 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Art Devlin (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Qty
View All + Want
Fair - 1.5
 $145 
$131 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Larry Doyle (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Qty
View All + Want
Fair - 1.5
 $135 
$122 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Bob Ganley (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 5 - EX
 $510 
$434 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
 $200 
$180 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Solly Hoffman (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Qty
View All + Want
Good - 2
 $150 
$135 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Harry Krause (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 1.5 - FAIR
 $125 
$113 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
 $110 
$99 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
John McGraw (MANAGER HALL-OF-FAME)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Giants
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 2.5 - GD+
 $470 
$423 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Danny Murphy (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Athletics
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 2 - GOOD
 $125 
$113 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
 $110 
$99 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Ed Reulbach (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Cubs
Qty
View All + Want
Fair - 1.5
 $165 
$149 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Jimmy Sheckard (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Qty
View All + Want
SGC 3 - VG
 $255 
$230 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
 $135 
$122 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
J.B. Seymour (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Qty
View All + Want
Good - 2
 $170 
$153 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Fred Tenney (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Qty
View All + Want
Fair - 1.5
 $145 
$131 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Ira Thomas (Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Qty
View All + Want
Fair - 1.5
 $145 
$131 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Joe Tinker (HALL-OF-FAME Type B)
View All + Want
1909 E91-B American Caramel Baseball Cards
Cubs
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 3 - VG
 $940 
$799 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart
SGC 2 - GOOD
 $500 
$425 after 15% discount
1
View Close + Cart

Page : 1

Dean's Cards® is a registered trademark of Dean's Cards, LLC. 2026

Report this card

Thank you for your report.

This dialog will close automatically.

Add To Cart Report
Please consider
leaving a review