Baseball Cards

Pre-War 1948 to 1959 1960s 1970s 1980s to Present

Football Cards

1930s to 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s to Present

Other Cards

Basketball Cards Soccer Cards Hockey Cards Boxing Cards Non-Sports Cards Reprint Cards Autographs

Sets

Complete Sets Starter & Near Sets Team Sets & Lots Reprint Sets

Magazines

Sports Illustrated (SI) The Sporting News (TSN) Sports Magazines MLB Team Publications Programs & Tickets

More

Wax Packs & Wrappers Gift Certificates

Baseball Cards

Pre-War 1948 to 1959 1960s 1970s 1980s to Present

Football Cards

1930s to 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s to Present

Other Cards

Basketball Cards Soccer Cards Hockey Cards Boxing Cards Non-Sports Cards Reprint Cards Autographs

Sets

Complete Sets Starter & Near Sets Team Sets & Lots Reprint Sets

Magazines

Sports Illustrated (SI) The Sporting News (TSN) Sports Magazines MLB Team Publications Programs & Score Cards

More

Wax Packs & Wrappers Gift Certificates

Tug McGraw

Frank Edwin "Tug" McGraw, Jr. (August 30, 1944 – January 5, 2004) was a Major League Baseball relief pitcher and the father of American singer and actor Tim McGraw. He is likely best remembered for coining the phrase, “Ya Gotta Believe” which became a popular rallying cry for the New York Mets, and for recording the final out, via a strikeout of the Kansas City Royals' Willie Wilson, in the 1980 World Series, bringing the Philadelphia Phillies their first world championship. He was the last active major league player to have played under manager Casey Stengel.

Hide Sets

Showing 1 to 50 of 50 products.

Page Size: 100 1000

Page : 1

#533 Mets Rookies - Tug McGraw / Ron Swoboda / Jim Bethke / Dan Napoleon (ROOKIE SHORT-PRINT)

View All

1965 Topps Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

PSA 6 - EX/MT

$150

$135 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$71.00

$67 after 5% discount

3

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5

$69.00

$66 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good+ - 3.5

$55.00

$52 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$50.00

$48 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$40.00

1

View Close + Cart

#124 Tug McGraw

View All

1966 Topps Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Near Mint - 7

$30.00

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$12.50

4

View Close + Cart

Excellent+ - 5.5

$11.00

2

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5

$6.25

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$4.00

4

View Close + Cart

Very Good+ - 3.5

$3.75

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$2.45

5

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$2.15

2

View Close + Cart

Poor - 1

$0.99

6

View Close + Cart

#124 Tug McGraw

View All

1966 Topps Venezuelan

Mets

Qty

View All

Fair - 1.5

$31.00

1

View Close + Cart

#348 Tug McGraw

View All

1967 Topps Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

PSA 8 - NM/MT

$85.00

$81 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$62.50

$59 after 5% discount

2

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$43.00

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$22.50

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$18.00

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$12.00

2

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$5.50

2

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$3.50

2

View Close + Cart

#236 Tug McGraw

View All

1968 Topps Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Near Mint+ - 7.5

$39.50

1

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$24.00

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$16.00

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$10.00

2

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$5.50

5

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$3.75

4

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$2.55

4

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$2.05

1

View Close + Cart

Poor - 1

$1.25

2

View Close + Cart

#601 Tug McGraw (HIGH-NUMBER)

View All

1969 Topps Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

PSA 8 - NM/MT

$305

$275 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Near Mint+ - 7.5

$180

$162 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

PSA 6 - EX/MT

$165

$149 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$120

$108 after 10% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$84.00

$80 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Poor - 1

$16.50

1

View Close + Cart

#26 Tug McGraw

View All

1970 Topps Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Near Mint - 7

$28.00

4

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint+ - 6.5

$23.00

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$12.00

6

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$10.00

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$6.25

3

View Close + Cart

Very Good+ - 3.5

$5.25

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$4.25

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$2.50

1

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$1.90

1

View Close + Cart

#26 Tug McGraw

View All

1970 O-Pee-Chee Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Excellent/Mint - 6

$10.50

1

View Close + Cart

#618 Tug McGraw

View All

1971 Topps Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

PSA 7 - NM

$53.50

$51 after 5% discount

1

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$28.50

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$20.00

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$12.00

2

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5

$9.75

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$8.25

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$5.00

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$4.00

1

View Close + Cart

#163 Tug McGraw

View All

1972 Topps Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Near Mint+ - 7.5

$28.50

1

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$12.00

3

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$7.25

5

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$3.75

6

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5

$4.00

2

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$3.00

3

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$2.15

3

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$1.30

2

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$0.99

3

View Close + Cart

#164 In Action - Tug McGraw

View All

1972 Topps Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Near Mint - 7

$12.00

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint+ - 6.5

$8.25

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$4.00

6

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$2.35

6

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$1.65

6

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$0.99

6

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$0.99

3

View Close + Cart

#163 Tug McGraw

View All

1972 O-Pee-Chee Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Excellent+ - 5.5

$8.75

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$7.25

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$2.50

1

View Close + Cart

#164 In Action - Tug McGraw

View All

1972 O-Pee-Chee Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Near Mint - 7

$7.00

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$5.00

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$0.99

3

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

#30 Tug McGraw

View All

1973 Topps Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$33.00

1

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$18.00

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint+ - 6.5

$14.50

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$10.00

4

View Close + Cart

Excellent+ - 5.5

$8.00

3

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$4.25

6

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5

$5.25

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$2.40

6

View Close + Cart

Very Good+ - 3.5

$2.95

2

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$1.90

4

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$1.35

4

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$0.99

5

View Close + Cart

Poor - 1

$0.99

4

View Close + Cart

#30 Tug McGraw

View All

1973 O-Pee-Chee Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Excellent - 5

$8.00

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$5.50

1

View Close + Cart

#21 Tug McGraw

View All

1973 Kelloggs

Mets

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$19.00

3

View Close + Cart

Near Mint+ - 7.5

$17.50

1

View Close + Cart

#265 Tug McGraw

View All

1974 Topps Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Excellent/Mint - 6

$16.00

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent+ - 5.5

$11.50

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$8.50

2

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5

$5.25

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$1.80

6

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$0.99

6

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$0.99

5

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$0.99

6

View Close + Cart

Poor - 1

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

#265 Tug McGraw

View All

1974 O-Pee-Chee Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$5.50

1

View Close + Cart

#67 Tug McGraw

View All

1975 Topps Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Near Mint+ - 7.5

$30.50

1

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$24.00

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint+ - 6.5

$15.00

3

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$10.50

4

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$5.75

3

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5

$5.00

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$3.75

3

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$1.55

3

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$1.40

2

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$1.10

1

View Close + Cart

Authentic

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

#67 Tug McGraw

View All

1975 Topps Mini

Mets

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$29.50

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$11.00

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$6.50

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$4.00

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$2.75

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$1.60

1

View Close + Cart

#149 Tug McGraw

View All

1975 Hostess

Phillies

Qty

View All

Excellent - 5

$6.75

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$4.50

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$1.95

1

View Close + Cart

#565 Tug McGraw

View All

1976 Topps Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$8.50

1

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$2.85

6

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint+ - 6.5

$3.75

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$2.85

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent+ - 5.5

$2.35

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$2.05

2

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good+ - 3.5

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$0.99

2

View Close + Cart

Good+ - 2.5

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

#565 Tug McGraw

View All

1976 O-Pee-Chee Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Excellent/Mint - 6

$4.50

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$3.00

1

View Close + Cart

#457 Tug McGraw

View All

1975-76 SSPC

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$2.25

5

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$1.95

1

View Close + Cart

#164 Tug McGraw

View All

1977 Topps Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$24.00

1

View Close + Cart

Near Mint+ - 7.5

$12.50

2

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$4.25

3

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint+ - 6.5

$3.75

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$1.75

6

View Close + Cart

Excellent+ - 5.5

$1.95

4

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$1.65

4

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$0.99

5

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

#142 Tug McGraw

View All

1977 O-Pee-Chee Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Excellent - 5

$2.50

1

View Close + Cart

#446 Tug McGraw

View All

1978 Topps Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$4.25

6

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$3.00

5

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$2.30

3

View Close + Cart

Excellent+ - 5.5

$2.05

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$1.75

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5

$1.25

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good+ - 3.5

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$0.99

2

View Close + Cart

Good+ - 2.5

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$0.99

4

View Close + Cart

Fair - 1.5

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

#345 Tug McGraw

View All

1979 Topps Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$2.60

6

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$1.60

6

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint+ - 6.5

$2.20

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$1.90

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent+ - 5.5

$1.50

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$0.99

6

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$0.99

1

View Close + Cart

#10 Tug McGraw

View All

1979 Burger King Phillies

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$22.00

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$6.00

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$3.50

4

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$3.25

1

View Close + Cart

Good - 2

$2.50

2

View Close + Cart

#176 Tug McGraw

View All

1979 O-Pee-Chee Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Excellent/Mint - 6

$2.95

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$1.60

2

View Close + Cart

#655 Tug McGraw

View All

1980 Topps Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$13.50

2

View Close + Cart

Near Mint+ - 7.5

$8.50

2

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$4.00

5

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint+ - 6.5

$3.75

2

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$2.60

3

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$2.00

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$1.00

1

View Close + Cart

#20 Tug McGraw

View All

1980 Topps Burger King Phillies

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint - 7

$16.00

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$6.00

2

View Close + Cart

Very Good/Excellent - 4

$4.50

1

View Close + Cart

Very Good - 3

$3.50

1

View Close + Cart

#40 Tug McGraw

View All

1981 Topps Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$5.00

2

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$3.25

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$2.65

1

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$1.30

2

View Close + Cart

#7 Tug McGraw

View All

1981 Fleer Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$0.99

6

View Close + Cart

#657 COR Tug McGraw (Number #657 on Back)

View All

1981 Fleer Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$3.50

2

View Close + Cart

#37 Tug McGraw

View All

1981 Kelloggs Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$2.80

6

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$2.80

1

View Close + Cart

#250 Tug McGraw

View All

1982 Topps Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint - 7

$1.05

6

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint - 6

$0.99

6

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$0.99

4

View Close + Cart

#251 Tug McGraw

View All

1982 Fleer Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$0.99

6

View Close + Cart

#510 Tug McGraw

View All

1983 Topps Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$1.80

6

View Close + Cart

Near Mint+ - 7.5

$2.40

1

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$2.00

2

View Close + Cart

#511 Super Veteran - Tug McGraw

View All

1983 Topps Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint+ - 8.5

$5.00

1

View Close + Cart

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$3.00

6

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$2.40

3

View Close + Cart

Excellent - 5

$1.05

1

View Close + Cart

#166 Tug McGraw

View All

1983 O-Pee-Chee Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$18.00

1

View Close + Cart

#187 Super Veteran - Tug McGraw

View All

1983 O-Pee-Chee Baseball Cards

Mets Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$18.00

1

View Close + Cart

#166 Tug McGraw

View All

1983 Fleer Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$5.00

1

View Close + Cart

#709 NL Active Save Leaders - Gene Garber / Bruce Sutter / Tug McGraw (HALL-OF-FAME)

View All

1984 Topps Baseball Cards

Braves Cardinals Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint+ - 8.5

$7.00

2

View Close + Cart

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$4.25

4

View Close + Cart

Excellent/Mint+ - 6.5

$2.75

1

View Close + Cart

#728 Tug McGraw

View All

1984 Topps Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$3.50

2

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$1.55

4

View Close + Cart

#42 Tug McGraw

View All

1984 Fleer Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$4.50

2

View Close + Cart

#157 Tug McGraw

View All

1985 Topps Baseball Cards

Phillies

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$2.05

5

View Close + Cart

Near Mint - 7

$1.20

5

View Close + Cart

#96 Tug McGraw

View All

1988 Pacific Legends I Baseball Cards

Mets

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$0.99

6

View Close + Cart

#87 Tug McGraw

View All

2001 Topps American Pie

Mets

Qty

View All

Near Mint/Mint - 8

$4.00

1

View Close + Cart

January 1981 - Tug McGraw

View All

Baseball Digest

Qty

View All

$7.50

6

View Close + Cart

Page : 1

Dean's Cards® is a registered trademark of Dean's Cards, LLC. 2026

Thank you for your report.

This dialog will close automatically.

Please consider
leaving a review